Revising Fiction – Shifting the “Bad First Draft” Mindset
When it comes to revising fiction—specifically, to reading one’s first draft for the first time—the experience is almost universally touted as being… bad. It’s a sentiment shared by literary giants who’ve written books on the writing craft and newbie writers posting reflections online about their writing experiences: a first draft is a pretty darn awful piece of writing. Reading it is painful.
On the one hand, I believe we’re attempting to be honest and realistic when we writers characterize our drafts in this way. However, I’d like to unpack our almost universal tendency to berate our first drafts. First, I don’t think it’s the whole story. Second, I think we may be inadvertently doing more damage to our process than good.
I think there’s a way to shift our “bad first draft” mindset and do ourselves a favour!
Are first drafts actually bad?
It’s a huge achievement to write a first draft. HUGE. You’ve created something start-to-finish that didn’t exist before. You are so much further ahead than you were when your story was merely an idea in your head or an outline in your notebook. Now you have something to shape, improve, and refine. You’ve taken a step—a leap!—toward making something you can share for feedback and coax toward its full potential.
Still, the words we often choose to describe our first drafts: garbage, rubbish, or junk (or some other four-letter gems). Why is that and is it as honest—and as helpful—as we think?
Novels are complex things. You’re not just stringing together words until you reach an impressive count (although you’re going to do need that, too). Story structure, pacing, a compelling plot, intriguing subplots, genre-specific features and conventions, your personal style, maybe your unique worldview or philosophy…these are just some of things we’re tapping into and balancing and honing as we attempt to express our story. It’s no wonder we writers don’t achieve perfection the first time through!
So, no—in short, I don’t believe that first drafts are bad! But I do believe that we writers often feel bad about our first drafts.
We often go into writing with such a strong vision for our stories that when we read it reflected back to us for the first time, we can’t believe how flat it feels, how short it falls when we compare it to the vision that’s been inspiring and motivating us. Based on that feeling, we blame the draft. We call it bad.
An Unnecessary Obstacle
If we’re being really honest, what’s often behind the usual “my draft is terrible” statement is shock and dismay at the results of a lot of effort, especially when our story feels so much better and alive and real in our brains. We seem to be forgetting what we know (or should know)—that novels are extremely complex entities, and that a great idea or vision is not (yet) a novel. The consequence, even if we berate our draft with a laugh, is that we’re putting ourselves in a place of defeat or set-back. It’s an exhausting, deflating place to be, even subconsciously. Revision is already hard work—why are we making it so much harder on ourselves?
Time for Refreshing Our Approach!
I’m not suggesting we all become delusional and declare our first drafts to be masterpieces, worthy of immediate sharing with readers and reviewers (they’re not—don’t do it!). I do think though that there’s a cost to the deprecating language we tend to use around first drafts. At the very least, you’ve made proceeding even tougher on yourself. At worst, declaring your draft to be “bad” can lead you to internalize that you are bad, hopeless, etc. at writing. Calling your draft a piece of “junk” can make you feel that you’re not up to the task of shaping your work into the story you once believed in and loved. I’ve seen it and been there before—abandoning a project because the first draft (or rather, my identity as a writer) is “bad”.
It’s time to swap the “bad draft” habit for a more helpful approach to our first drafts. I’m calling it the Three Rs of Revising Fiction—Rest, Reframe, and Read.
REST
If I were to declare one non-negotiable rule when it comes to reading your first draft, it’s to put it aside before you do so. You need to put time and space between yourself and your vision in order to truly see what you have produced in your first draft. A few weeks, maybe even a few months.
True, coming back after a rest is going to reveal plenty of problems and challenges that you’ll want to address in order to polish your story into the best version of itself. But that’s to be expected in something that we know and accept is a step in our process, not the finished product. If you let it, your time away will also let you see what’s already working. Which leads us to…
REFRAME
I’ve argued above that first drafts aren’t actually bad, so let’s stop using that word or any other words that imply a value judgment. Here are some alternatives:
Raw.
Rough.
Unpolished.
Fledgling.
Working copy.
Or how about…First draft.
These neutral terms respect the stages of the writing process—in fact, they respect the fact that writing is a process! You’re also respecting and protecting your writer’s self and your potential in a way that calling your work “bad”, “awful”, “dreadful” never will.
READ
I mean this quite literally. After your rest, and after you’ve reframed your expectations, I advocate for a first read-through of your draft where you don’t revise, edit or make any notes—you just read. This is easier said than done, but it’s well worth it.
The idea here is to get a feel for the big picture, the rhythm, the mood and tone already coming through even in this rough or raw draft. If you must markup your text on this pass, highlight sentences or scenes that you love or that represent solid areas you can build upon in your subsequent revisions.
Reading your draft the first time without making changes helps signal to your brain that a first draft is not merely a bad piece of writing in immediate need of ripping apart and fixing. It’s a step in the writing process where you’ve produced a version of your emerging story. Reading once through without correction lets you appreciate your achievement, rough and raw as it is.
For more tips on revising fiction and on all the steps of the novel-writing process, please check out my book The One Week Writing Workshop.
You can do this writers – and congrats on writing that first draft! 😉